In a recent episode of his podcast, Supercross legend Ricky Carmichael shared an intriguing idea that has sparked interest across the racing world. Carmichael, known for his dominance in the sport and his insight into the evolution of motocross, proposed a unique challenge: a one-time “Skill vs. Tech” race between the legendary racers of the past and the current crop of riders.
The core of Carmichael’s idea revolves around the idea of contrasting two different approaches to Supercross: the skill-based racing of previous eras and the technology-driven focus of modern-day riders. Carmichael, who earned the nickname “The GOAT” for his unparalleled success in the sport, expressed his frustration that today’s riders—while undeniably talented—are often more reliant on advanced technology and bikes equipped with the latest gadgets.
According to Carmichael, while these riders possess remarkable speed and fitness, they may not fully grasp the essence of what Supercross once stood for: raw skill. In his time, the key to success was mastering the art of control, precision, and innovation, often relying on natural talent and a deep understanding of the bike, the track, and the elements of the sport. Carmichael’s comment, “Skills were the ultimate, and they still are,” underscores his belief that today’s racers—while impressive in many ways—lack that fundamental connection with the sport’s deeper roots.
Carmichael specifically mentioned the current crop of racers, including Eli Tomac, Jett Lawrence, Ken Roczen, and Haiden Deegan, praising their abilities while suggesting that they would face a real challenge in matching the raw skill of himself, James Stewart, Ryan Villopoto, and Jeremy McGrath—the “legends” of the sport. “Today’s racers like Tomac, Deegan, Jett, Ken are good,” Carmichael said, “but can they match the skills of myself, Ryan, James, and Jeremy?”
This proposed “Skill vs. Tech” race would offer a fascinating showdown, pitting the old school against the new. The premise would involve a track designed to test rider skill rather than speed or technology—possibly incorporating obstacles and challenges that emphasize finesse, technique, and adaptability. Carmichael and his fellow legends would undoubtedly have the upper hand in this format, showcasing that skillful riding is still at the heart of the sport.
While it’s unclear whether this race will ever come to fruition, Carmichael’s comments spark an important discussion on the changing nature of Supercross. Are today’s bikes and technology allowing riders to bypass some of the skill-building that defined previous generations, or is the sport simply evolving in a way that requires a different set of expertise?
For now, Carmichael’s proposal remains a conversation starter—a tribute to the skill that once ruled the sport and a challenge to the new generation to understand and appreciate its true essence.
